Name: Supreme Pizza & Subs
Price range: $$

Supreme Pizza & Subs Information

If you're cruising down Main Street in Walpole and craving some classic comfort food, Supreme Pizza & Subs at 885 Main St, Walpole, MA 02081, United States, is the kind of spot that feels instantly familiar yet reliably satisfying. Walking in, you’re greeted by the aroma of freshly baked dough and sizzling toppings, setting the tone for a casual, no-fuss dining experience that locals rave about. The menu leans heavily on the essentials done exceptionally well-crispy, golden pizzas with perfectly balanced sauce and cheese, hearty subs stacked with fresh deli meats, and a few inventive twists that keep regulars coming back. Many diners highlight the Supreme Pizza itself as a standout, loaded with generous toppings that stay flavorful without overwhelming the crust, which strikes a nice balance between chewy and crisp. Service tends to be warm and approachable, whether you’re ordering to go or settling in for a sit-down meal, and the staff often takes the time to make recommendations for first-timers or those torn between a classic cheese pie and a loaded Italian sub. Portions are generous, making it easy to share or enjoy leftovers, and the pricing feels fair for the quality and freshness delivered. While the interior is straightforward and unpretentious, the atmosphere has a friendly, small-town charm that makes it more than just a quick stop-it’s a place where neighbors chat over lunch and families grab dinner after a busy day. Reviewers frequently note that the consistency is what keeps them loyal, with each visit reliably delivering that perfect mix of comfort, flavor, and satisfying heartiness. If you’re in the mood for a casual meal that hits the familiar notes of pizza and subs but still manages to feel personal and welcoming, Supreme Pizza & Subs is the kind of place that earns repeat visits without fuss, embodying that classic local pizzeria vibe that’s hard to beat.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

I stopped by for two slices one buffalo chicken and one classic cheese and both were absolutely fantastic. There was plenty of seating available, and the owner and the pizza chef were really friendly. It’s a great spot to come with your family, and they have a large parking area too, so it’s super convenient.

YES, YOU SHOULD EAT HERE, NEW OWNER MADE THIS PLACE GREAT this is by far the best pizza shop I've been to in many years. Pizza is remarkable, not greasy, perfect crust and high quality toppings. I usually get chicken pizza, bbq or buffalo or a combo of both, tried pastrami pizza today... It was amazing. I spoke briefly with the owner and he is a very nice man who clearly cares a lot about his shop and the food that he makes for us. It's the kind of place where you don't worry about anything, you know it's gonna be fresh from a clean kitchen every time. Can not recommend this place enough, order a bbq chicken pizza now, stop reading this and go order the pie... What are you still doing here? Get the pizza!

One bite and you’re hooked. This place has completely spoiled us for pizza anywhere else. The crust is perfectly baked, the sauce is rich and flavorful, and the toppings are always fresh and generous. Every item we’ve tried has been outstanding — not just the pizza, but all the food. It’s one of those rare spots where the whole family agrees on dinner, and everyone ends up fighting over the last slice. If you’re debating where to order from tonight, stop thinking and order here. You won’t regret it.

The owner was extremely polite and food was excellent. I will come back. Great first time here

Friendly and affordable. The pizza has the texture of Pizza Hut Pizza. It’s not New York style and it’s not brick oven pizza, so some people like that better than others. It’s not my favorite. My one complaint was that the pizza is kept in a container that is not heated or anything so it does make me wonder how long is it sitting on the counter. You have to have it reheated if you just buy a slice. I don’t mind to have it reheated I just like to know that it’s fresh. Enjoyed my slice. Plenty of seating and very accessible.

A new owner who cares about every little detail! New owner Arz has taken Supreme Pizza from a disaster area to... well; a new menu with recipes that hes been making for a long time, cleaned the entire place ceiling to floor, front to back. Displaying his inspection for all to see. This place has done a 180 and I live in Leomisnter MA. but since I had the food at Supreme pizza in July 2025 ive been back 2 more times. I live an hour away, ive looked for a similar place near my home... nothing comes close to Supreme. So whenever I am in the Walpole area I will mention Supreme Pizza when I arrive, and if nobody else wants anything I will stop by on my way home. Arz and the rest of the staff are all hard workers, friendly, and willing to explain anything you need to know. I am honestly thinking that the food here is worth the wait, and I can avoid all Pizza and subs to wait for the next trip to the walpole area. Its really that good. And uniquely different from anyplace ive tried to search for where I live. Everything is seasoned perfectly, nothing is bland and that is what I find anytime I tried to find something close to what I get at Supreme. I know now I never will. Gotta try it. I HIGHLY recommend trying it out.

The food here was is amazing. And the customer service is just as great. Karen is such a nice lady. You can tell that this is a loving family business. If you go there get the steak and rice pilaf , it’s mouth watering. I give this place a 10 across the board. Til next time

Best eggplant on garlic bread in the WORLD!! As well as the owner, Arz is super honest and wants honesty back. This is my truth. I will drive hours for this Eggplant Sub!!!

Supreme Pizza & Subs